Billionaire Bill Ackman Just Bought Hertz. Is the Car Rental Stock a Buy?

Jeremy Bowman, The Motley Fool

Mon, Apr 21, 2025, 1:35 AM 5 min read

Billionaire Bill Ackman is one of the most closely followed investors. The head of Pershing Square Capital Management is known for betting on beaten-down big-brand stocks like Chipotle and Nike, and he's never hesitant to share his opinion, whether it's on the markets, politics, or another issue.

So it wasn't a surprise to see Hertz Global (NASDAQ: HTZ) stock skyrocket after Ackman's fund disclosed a stake in the car rental business. Hertz shares jumped 126% in a two-day span as of trading on Thursday afternoon as his purchase of a nearly 20% stake in the longtime laggard breathed new life into the stock.

Where to invest $1,000 right now? Our analyst team just revealed what they believe are the 10 best stocks to buy right now. Continue »

In a filing Wednesday, Pershing Square disclosed a purchase of 12.7 million shares in the struggling car rental stock worth $46.5 million at the time, though that value has since more than doubled. The purchase made Pershing Square Hertz's second-largest shareholder.

Ackman didn't comment on the purchase, but it fits in with the beaten-down consumer stocks that he's purchased before like Chipotle and Nike. His Pershing Square fund also took a large stake in Uber Technologies earlier this year, and that, combined with Hertz, seems to show an increased interest in the transportation sector.

The move is also notable because it comes at a time when uncertainty has soared in the stock market. Hertz has historically been sensitive to the economic cycle since it depends on business travel and tourism for rentals. Still, Ackman's purchase of $46.5 million is a relatively small stake compared to Pershing Square's assets under management of $18.3 billion.

The car rental sector has long been a challenging one for investors, and the industry now competes with ride-sharing options like Uber and Lyft. The company was also forced to declare bankruptcy during the pandemic but restructured its debt to emerge as a leaner company.

Hertz is the second-largest car rental company in the world behind Enterprise and brought in $9.05 billion last year. However, revenue declined in 2024, falling 3.4% year over year as it faced challenges related to an over-investment in electric vehicles. That misjudgment led to an asset impairment of $1 billion and a $2.9 billion generally accepted accounting principles (GAAP) net loss last year due to higher-than-normal depreciation relating to the EVs.

With that challenge now effectively in the rearview mirror, Ackman seems to be betting that Hertz can become a healthy company even as the stock was still down sharply from the EV issues. As the chart below shows, Hertz had lost nearly 90% of its value over the last three years, before the news that Ackman had taken a stake in the company.